Dirty Nasty Filthy vs Drinking Tabs: Adult Card Game Showdown
By BBD Brands | Published: 2026-10-30
Category: Comparisons
Dirty Nasty Filthy rewards a filthy mind; Drinking Tabs rewards a full glass. Compare both party card games and pick the right one for your night.
Quick answer
Choose Dirty Nasty Filthy if your group likes raunchy humor and creative one-upmanship; choose Drinking Tabs if you want fast, peel-and-play drinking challenges with no rulebook. They serve different party moods, so pick based on whether your night is about dirty talk or drinking dares.
Humor style: creative smut vs. drinking dares
Dirty Nasty Filthy is built around sexual innuendo and outrageous phrases. The catalog says whoever has the most obscene mind wins, so the fun comes from players inventing or delivering filthy lines. That makes it a performance game: the loudest, quickest wit usually takes the lead.
Drinking Tabs is a peel-and-reveal challenge game. Each tab gives a drinking challenge or activity, so the humor comes from the dares themselves rather than from players crafting jokes. If your group prefers doing shots to trading punchlines, this is the more natural fit.
Setup and pacing: rulebook vs. no rules
Drinking Tabs requires almost no explanation: shake out tabs, peel, and follow the challenge. That makes it easy to start mid-party or hand to guests who arrive late. Dirty Nasty Filthy needs a group willing to lean into the premise and keep the filthy phrases coming; the payoff is a longer, more interactive session rather than a quick round.
Neither game supplies a timer or score pad in the catalog facts, so plan your own pacing if you want structured rounds.
Group size and audience fit
Dirty Nasty Filthy is described for two players or a whole party, so it scales from a couple to a crowd. Drinking Tabs is designed for friends in a party setting, with 50 tabs per box giving plenty of rounds for a group.
Both are adult-oriented. Dirty Nasty Filthy is explicitly sexual in tone, while Drinking Tabs centers on alcohol. If your guest list mixes drinkers and non-drinkers, Drinking Tabs may leave some people on the sidelines; if your group is shy about raunchy talk, Dirty Nasty Filthy will fall flat.
Key trade-offs to weigh
- Creative involvement vs. passive participation: Dirty Nasty Filthy asks players to generate or deliver filthy phrases, so the energy depends on how outgoing the group is. Drinking Tabs hands players a challenge to perform, which keeps quieter guests involved without requiring them to invent anything. If your group includes wallflowers, Drinking Tabs lowers the pressure.
- Alcohol-centered vs. humor-centered: Drinking Tabs is built around drinking challenges, so it suits nights where alcohol is part of the fun. Dirty Nasty Filthy is built around sexual innuendo, so it suits nights where raunchy humor is the main event. Match the game to what your party is already about.
- Replay value and variety: Drinking Tabs offers 50 unique challenges per box, giving a finite but broad set of dares. Dirty Nasty Filthy relies on player creativity, so its variety comes from the people at the table rather than a fixed deck of prompts. For repeat parties with the same crowd, Dirty Nasty Filthy may feel fresher longer.
Product facts at a glance
- Dirty Nasty Filthy Card Game: Described as a hilarious card game for two or a whole party where the most obscene mind wins. It works for couples or large groups, but rewards players who enjoy dirty humor and quick thinking.
Dirty Nasty Filthy Card Game - Drinking Tabs Game: Each box contains 50 unique drinking challenges and activities on peel-back tabs. You get dozens of ready-to-play dares without needing a rulebook or a host to explain the game.
Drinking Tabs Game
Which game fits your night?
Best for
- Groups who love raunchy humor and quick-witted trash talk
- Couples or parties that want an interactive, adult-themed icebreaker
Not for
- Guests who are easily offended by sexual innuendo
- Parties where drinking games are the main focus
